Blog

HandBrake for videos in Apple Photos: what it doesn’t do for you

4 min read

Ask how to make a video smaller and someone will say HandBrake. As an encoder it is excellent; KeepFeather uses the same x265 inside. But HandBrake works with files, and your videos live in Apple Photos, with albums, Favorites, captions and dates attached. Everything between the library and the encoder is left to you.

Facts about HandBrake are from its release notes and documentation, version 1.11.2.

At a glance

KeepFeather HandBrake
Works with the Photos library Reads it directly, imports copies back No; export every file first and import the results
Finds the videos taking the most space Lists your 4K videos by size, with an estimate per clip No
Dolby Vision Kept and compared frame by frame, automatically Only if you pick a 10-bit H.265 encoder; the default preset drops it
Capture date and location Written and checked Preserved since 1.10 if Passthru common Metadata is on; off in the Social presets
Albums, Favorite, Hidden Carried over You redo them in Photos
Title, caption, keywords from Photos Copied and read back You retype them
Checks the copy Before import and again after No
Originals Kept until you press a button and confirm; saved to a folder by default You delete them in Photos yourself
Price Free for 3 videos, then $29 once Free

The round trip, clip by clip

With HandBrake, every video makes this trip:

  1. Find the big videos. Photos doesn’t list videos by file size, so this means a smart album of videos and some guessing.
  2. Export each one with File → Export → Export Unmodified Original.
  3. Add them to HandBrake’s queue with the right settings and wait.
  4. Import the results into Photos.
  5. Check that each copy landed on the right date and place.
  6. Add each copy to the albums the original was in, mark Favorites again, paste titles and captions.
  7. Delete the originals.

HandBrake can’t help with steps 1, 5 and 6, because albums, Favorites and captions are stored in Photos, not in the video file. People on MacRumors who have done a whole library this way describe it as a project for several weekends. The mistakes show up months later, when a video isn’t in the album where you expected it.

KeepFeather does all seven. It lists your 4K videos by size with an estimate of what each will be after, adds the copies to Photos together with their albums, copies Favorite, Hidden, title, caption and keywords, reads each copy back from Photos and compares it with the original, and puts the original in a “To be deleted” album. You press one button to move the originals to Recently Deleted, and macOS asks you to confirm. Start the queue in the evening; turn on quiet mode and the fan stays under the speed you choose.

Settings that quietly lose things

HandBrake gives you every option, which also means every way to get it wrong:

  • The default preset drops Dolby Vision. Fast 1080p30 uses the x264 encoder. Dolby Vision passes through only with the 10-bit H.265 encoders (x265 since 1.7, Apple’s VideoToolbox since 1.8).
  • 8-bit encoders can’t keep 10-bit HDR. Pick one by accident and the copy loses its 10-bit color for good.
  • The Colorspace filter turns off Dolby Vision and other dynamic HDR metadata when it is on.
  • The Social presets don’t pass metadata through. Use one, and the copy loses the original capture date and location.
  • Nothing tells you afterwards. HandBrake encodes what you asked for. If a setting was wrong, you find out when the clip shows up dated today, or looks flat on your iPhone.

KeepFeather makes these decisions per clip from the file itself. iPhone Dolby Vision goes the Dolby Vision path, HDR stays 10-bit with its original transfer curve, and clips that would lose something, like Slo-mo or Cinematic, are left out of Select Safe Clips and need your confirmation.

Every copy is checked

Before a copy goes into Photos, KeepFeather checks its length, dimensions, that it is smaller, the date, location and camera, HDR, and for Dolby Vision the metadata of every frame against the original and that macOS can play it. A copy that fails is kept aside for you to look at and never imported. After import it checks again, this time what Photos itself shows. The full list is on How it works.

If you still want to do it by hand

These HandBrake settings keep an iPhone video as close to the original as HandBrake can:

  • Video Encoder: H.265 10-bit (x265), or H.265 10-bit (VideoToolbox) if speed matters more than size.
  • Quality: Constant Quality, around RF 22 for x265. Compress one clip and compare it with the original on the screen you watch on.
  • Framerate: Same as source. iPhones record a variable frame rate.
  • Resolution: 1080p for most clips; 4K only for clips you might edit later.
  • Summary tab: Passthru common Metadata on.
  • Filters: Colorspace off.

Then do steps 4 to 7 for every clip, and check a few dates before deleting anything. Our guide to compressing videos in Photos without losing the date and location goes through the checks.

Or let KeepFeather do the trip

Same encoder, none of the round trip. Compress your first three videos free, with every feature, and see whether the weekends you get back are worth $29.