iCloud storage full? Shrink your videos instead of paying for 2 TB
The message says your iCloud storage is full, and the button under it offers a bigger plan. In the US, going from 200 GB to 2 TB adds $7 a month, $84 a year. Going from 2 TB to 6 TB adds $20 a month, $240 a year. You pay it for as long as you keep the files, and the library keeps growing.
Before you tap that button, it is worth five minutes to see what is actually filling the space. For most people the answer is a few hundred videos, and videos can be made much smaller without deleting any of them.
See what is using your iCloud
On an iPhone, open Settings, tap your name, then iCloud. The bar at the top shows what takes the most; tap Storage or Manage Account Storage for the full list. On a Mac, open System Settings, click your name, then iCloud, then Manage.
If Photos and Videos (or just Photos) is the biggest item, keep reading. If it is backups or a large Drive folder, the rest of this article won’t help much.
Why videos, and not photos
A photo from a recent iPhone takes a few megabytes. A minute of video takes a lot more. On an iPhone 12, Settings → Camera → Record Video listed about 170 MB for a minute of 4K at 30 frames per second and 400 MB for 4K at 60, a bit more with HDR on. Check the same screen on your own phone.
So a ten-minute school concert in 4K at 60 fps is around 4 GB, the space of a thousand or more photos. A few dozen clips like that, and a 200 GB plan is full.
Our own numbers, from the developer’s library: 110 videos took up 255 GB. The single biggest was a 23.8 GB clip.
What doesn’t help
Optimize iPhone Storage and Optimize Mac Storage free space on the device, not in iCloud. Apple’s own description is clear: the device keeps smaller versions while iCloud keeps the originals at full resolution. Turning it on changes nothing about the iCloud bar.
Deleting screenshots and duplicate photos is good housekeeping. It rarely frees more than a few gigabytes, because photos aren’t where the space went.
Your options
1. Pay for a bigger plan. The simplest answer. It works, and if your library is mostly photos it is probably the right one. The cost repeats every month.
2. Move videos to a drive and delete them from Photos. It costs a drive. But the videos are no longer on your phone, no longer in your albums or in Photos search, and a single drive is a single point of failure.
3. Make the videos smaller. Every video stays in Photos, on every device, in the same albums. It just takes a fraction of the space.
Why videos shrink so much
An iPhone has to compress video in real time, on a phone, while you are filming. It plays safe and uses a lot of data per second. A Mac with time to spare can encode the same picture much more efficiently, with an encoder that looks at each scene properly.
On top of that, most of us watch phone videos on phones, laptops and TVs, where 1080p looks nearly the same as 4K. Reduce a 4K clip to 1080p, encode it carefully, and the copy is often a third to a tenth of the size.
On the home page there is a frame you can compare yourself: the original at 58.6 Mbps and the copy at 17.1 Mbps, still Dolby Vision and still 60 frames per second. Across those 110 videos, 255 GB became 31 GB. The 23.8 GB clip became 1.6 GB.
The catch
The hard part is putting the copy back in Photos. The obvious way loses things:
- The date and place. The copy shows up dated today, with no location. Why that happens and how to avoid it.
- Albums, Favorites and captions. These live in Photos, not in the file, so a re-imported copy has none of them.
- HDR and Dolby Vision. Many tools flatten iPhone HDR or drop Dolby Vision. What to check.
Done by hand with free tools, it is possible, and people on MacRumors who have done it describe a library as a project for several weekends.
Doing it with KeepFeather
KeepFeather is a Mac app that does the whole round trip:
- It scans your Photos library and lists your 4K videos by size, with an estimate of how big each will be after and how much space you would get back in total.
- You pick clips, or let Select Safe Clips pick every clip that keeps all its features in the copy (Slo-mo and Cinematic clips, for example, are left out), and check the quality first if you like: Compare plays the original next to up to five compressed versions.
- It makes the copies, checks each one, and adds it to Photos in the same albums, with the same date, place, Favorite, title and caption.
- When you are happy, you press Move Originals to Recently Deleted… and confirm.
Two things about Recently Deleted are worth knowing. According to Apple, items there don’t count towards your iCloud storage, so the space comes back as soon as the originals are moved. And if you are already over your limit, Photos deletes them immediately instead of keeping them for 30 days. That is why KeepFeather saves a copy of each original to a folder on your Mac by default. Keep that folder, or move it to an external drive, until you have watched a few of the copies.
The copies then upload to iCloud and appear on your iPhone and iPad like any other video.
The math
KeepFeather Pro is $29, once, for up to three Macs. The first three videos are free, with every feature, so you can see the result on your own clips before paying anything. Against $84 a year for going from 200 GB to 2 TB, it pays for itself in about four months, and you keep every video.
If your library is mostly photos, a bigger plan may be the simpler fix. If it is full of 4K video, shrinking the videos first is the cheaper way out, and it keeps working: the next time iCloud fills up, run it again on the new clips.